|
 |
|
|
It's truly hard to get a read on you. I feel like you live for arguments and the line gets blurred on whether your arguing your thought process out of passion or frustration
|
|
 |
|
Edit: What's with your quoting back "Wild" at me? Was it that insulting to you? I feel like that's quite an non offensive way to show disagreement my dude
I'm sorry, it meant to be more as a joke to counter you with your statement in the discussion. Definitely wasn't insulting for me and wasn't used it to insult you either. |
|
|
|
In what world is any amount of Store TP diminishing returns when you're riding AM3 on Tizona for a flat DA/TA buff that gets cut off when you slot Any amount of hard DA/TA?
You are clearly in the wrong here. With Tizona/Thribon you clearly want to use Hoxne. Not only you don't need to hold TP for AM3 (it's so *** awesome QoL, when you don't need to do it), but also avg multi attack from AM3 is 1.8 attack per round on JUST Tizona. Hoxne is 2.0 attacks per round on BOTH Tizona and Thribon. It's massive gain you would understand very fast in practice too. I used BLU with Hoxne a lot recently in Segments. I was easily parsing like 20% higher than before.
This is also very visible in the sim. Fastest AM3 tp set without Hoxne (with II Samurai roll) is at 2.9 sec (though I would never use it, because it uses 2 Adhemar pieces and Samnuha pants, which is WAY to glassy). Now with Hoxne it goes down to 2.453 (using better more defensive gear too). That's almost 19% faster. If you apply more realistic set to AM3 (which ironically is 5/5 Sworn set), that difference goes up to almost 21%.
With Hoxne you can also use AM1 and AM2 to get accuracy or magic accuracy, because you are not glued to AM3 anymore. |
|
|
|
Carbuncle.Maletaru said: »Sure, that's also true of every stat in the game and a meaningless comparison.
If you have 10% DA, then adding 1% DA increases your DA by 10%. If you have 50% DA, then adding 1% DA increases your DA by 2%.
But it still increases the chance you will double-attack by 1 percentage point. It has the same value as every other DA ever (ignoring TA, QA, etc.)
It's not meaningless when you compare it against other stat in the calculation.
If you have 0% multi attack and 0 store TP, 25 store TP will beat 10%TA. If you have 100 store TP and 0% multi attack, 10%TA will beat 25 store TP. This is what I meant in above Samurai roll example. With Samurai roll, store tp on Justice set is weaker in comparison against TA on Trust, than it would be without Samurai roll. |
|
|
|
Given the chance, if all of the sets were all jobs, I truly believe every single DD would gravitate towards the Mithra set. That doesn't really mean anything. Most people only see pure DD stats on gear and undervalue defensive stats. Aren't you even complain about this on podcast? Kinda "wild" of you to use those people judgment as an argument in discussion now :D |
|
 |
|
Carbuncle.Maletaru said: »Um, what?
Not sure what you mean here?
In the calculation
base TP x store TP x multi attack
If you have 0 store TP, 50 store TP will increase your TP gain by 50%. If you have 100 store TP and add 50 store TP, your TP gain will increase by 25%.
There was a big discussion once to not call that diminishing returns of store TP, because theoretically you still gets the same +TP from each +1 store TP, but RELATIVE VALUE of each additional store TP is lower with each store TP you already have.
Sure, that's also true of every stat in the game and a meaningless comparison.
If you have 10% DA, then adding 1% DA increases your DA by 10%. If you have 50% DA, then adding 1% DA increases your DA by 2%.
But it still increases the chance you will double-attack by 1 percentage point. It has the same value as every other DA ever (ignoring TA, QA, etc.) |
|
 |
By Asura. Vyre on 2026-01-12 19:53:49 |
|
Kaffy done did delete his account? Say h-wut? o_o;
|
|
|
|
Carbuncle.Maletaru said: »Um, what?
Not sure what you mean here?
In the calculation
base TP x store TP x multi attack
If you have 0 store TP, 50 store TP will increase your TP gain by 50%. If you have 100 store TP and add 50 store TP, your TP gain will increase by 25%.
There was a big discussion once to not call that diminishing returns of store TP, because theoretically you still gets the same +TP from each +1 store TP, but RELATIVE VALUE of each additional store TP is lower with each store TP you already have. |
|
|
|
I feel like you invoking the ampulla as some sort of standard comes across incredibly unserious...
We are compering sets, which take 10 months of serious grind to get and hundreds of millions of gils to buy HQ1 or HQ2. I would say buyable ammo is far more standard than those sets will ever be. |
|
|
|
I guess you do you dude. If you're one of those people that wants to Hoxne at all times for every single job then you're not really going to listen to anyone but yourself anyway
I literally said "if I would be that serious to kill something", meaning I would use it for stuff like Sortie bosses or V25, not trash. I also gave you reasoning for scenario with and WITHOUT Hoxne and your argument is "You want to use Hoxne at all times"...
You are clearly the one who is not listening anyone but yourself here. |
|
 |
|
Using Kastra sim like that is /facepalm. I edited in a disclaimer just for you. If I need to make it stand out more you just let me know :) |
|
|
|
You're wild for not thinking the justice set isnt the best.... it literally has Everything you want in a TP set. The Trust set is solid sure, but niche, and mainly good for red mage useage outside of macro swaps for the other jobs. If you want to make the arguement that Trust is a huge step up as a TP set for any of the jobs... then Justice would be far better if the jobs were on it.
Im not really wild.
First of all Sworn set has 114 MEVA and 10DT more, which is huge difference.
Second of all it has 15%TA more, while having 25%DA and 34sTP less. So generally it has less TP gain, but not by much, because TA% on Justice set devalues DA% (and many jobs have some additional TA% outside of main slots, like Moonbow belt, Gere Ring, Foenaria, Trait) and store TP has diminishing value with Samurai roll.
Third of all Hoxne Ampulla exists and it's so strong for many jobs on those 2 sets, that you can't simply ignore it. All that DA% on Justice set is useless stat with Hoxne. I presented more fact checking in MNK thread. Even without Hoxne you would mainly use Justice body with impetus down and feet and head (if you dont have Nyame A, which you should if you are MNK main). With Hoxne you would use even less.
For BLU without Hoxne, Duty set would be like 7% faster TP gain, but I would never want to drop that meva and dt for it and if I would be that serious to kill something, I would use Hoxne for massive TP gain and combo of Sworn and Malignance for TA/sTP and keeping top defensive stats.
TL;DR In most buff scenario without Hoxne, Sworn set is just slightly less TP gain than Duty set, with 114 meva and 10DT advantage, which I definitely prefer. With Hoxne Sworn+Malignance mix is break even against Duty for TP gain, while still having that that additional MEVA and DT.
I guess you do you dude. If you're one of those people that wants to Hoxne at all times for every single job then you're not really going to listen to anyone but yourself anyway |
|
 |
|
|
For Botulus, I make Liquefaction SC + 3K tp Shining strike for fusion. I got charmed maybe 4 times out of maybe 60 runs. It happened today. I sleep II it. Run to basenent. Go back after putting trusts back on and start again.
|
|
|
By Streak on 2026-01-12 18:28:23 |
|
You can clear all content in the game with R15 Godhands.
Verethragna has very very low base damage and Victory Smite is a very inconsistent WS against high tier content.
If you're mowing down easier content either weapon is fine but I have stage 5 prime and I'll still use Godhands against things like V25 Ngai.
|
|
|
|
|
Hello fellow Friars of the fist. I'm a somewhat returning player from some time ago and would like to get into playing Monk. I've been tooling around on it with 5/5 Malignance and have so far invested in the neck +2 and Moonbow Belt +1.
I'm having a hard time figuring out what weapon I should try to sink my teeth into. I have empy at 90 and was planning to do that, until I read here how Godhands isn't really behind empy or how Godhands can pull ahead. I really do not want to sink millions into something second class.
My issue is getting a group to do aeonic weapon runs. Money I can at least farm solo and eventually get the empy done. I really need advice on what exactly to do. I mostly play solo or low man content as of right now. Using Denouncements currently and really wanting to upgrade. Any advice is appreciated!
|
|
|
|
|
I buff what i can before entering Sortie. I use Marine stewpot on me and trusts.
For Ghatjot, I melee him and use Yoran-Oran, Kupipi (he removes silence very fast), Ulmia, Cornelia and King of Hearts.
I start with Geohelix II non MB for 10K+.
I use Haste Samba. Dual wield Maxenxius + Bunzi.
Immanence WIND ELEMENT+ BLACK HALO for GRAVITATION skillchain.
I MB for 50-53K normally.
Rinse and repeat until dead.
I beat my record today and killed it in 3:15 :)
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Lol I would never want BLU to be on different set. Trust set is by far the best one with Mercy being second best. Justice probably 3rd and Hope 4th.
The amount of defensive stats on Trust set alongside that Triple attack is just borderline broken. Especially on jobs that also has Sakpata/Malignance hands and Null back is bis for them. The amount of meva in this set is ridiculous. Not to mention all the other uses for this set like casting buffs, debuffs with massive acc/macc and cooldown reduction thx to Fast Cast (you can reduce cooldown on TP reset spells for example). It's bis tanking set. Mostly bis idle. I think some pieces can even be bis for white wind with that much HP.
And all that TPing and casting while being the most tanky is just pure win. Having sword enhancement isn't perfect, but having something like sTP instead would make this set super unbalanced vs other 4.
You're wild for not thinking the justice set isnt the best.... it literally has Everything you want in a TP set. The Trust set is solid sure, but niche, and mainly good for red mage useage outside of macro swaps for the other jobs. If you want to make the arguement that Trust is a huge step up as a TP set for any of the jobs... then Justice would be far better if the jobs were on it. |
|
|
|
|
This is my engaged set:
sets.engaged.Melee = {
main="Daybreak", sub="Bunzi's Rod",
ammo="Oshasha's Treatise",
head="Blistering Sallet +1",
body="Nyame Mail",
hands="Gazu Bracelets +1",
legs="Nyame Flanchard",
feet="Nyame Sollerets",
neck="Null Loop",
waist="Null Belt",
left_ear="Crep. Earring",
right_ear="Mache Earring +1",
left_ring="Lehko's Ring",
right_ring="Chirich Ring",
back="Null Shawl",
}
|
|
|
|
|
You know I’ve always thought of it as Rent a Shield, Airbnb shield. Have always accepted payment per synth. But actually after reading some comments gave a good idea. Easier just to charge by the Activation of the shield, all u want 30mins for 10M. Thanks for the input. I’ll craft and try whatever for 30min you keep whatever results.
Thanks.
|
|
|
|
|
It would be cool if in the mog garden / monster rearing area
There was a connected zone where only BST could enter
Were you could strengthen pets
Like there doing with trusts
Keep a charmed pet > Give a new Job ability to summon it
Also a new job trait that let's BST use pets as mounts
What else?
Monstrosity? Maybe BST goes here to do something pet related
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Who was demanding X tip for HQ? Atleast not in my post. If someone else said that, that’s their business model. Mine is you keep what you get but X amount per try.
More HQs the better, brings more business.
|
|
 |
By . on 2026-01-12 16:26:11 |
Woah........... A Parasite Eve like new game
Quote: Parasite Eve-inspired sci-fi horror RPG Parasite Mutant announced for PS5 Quote: Parasite Mutant is a survival horror RPG that uses Active Time Chain system. Players play as Psionic Agent Nova who is on a mission to investigate a mysterious abandoned island city, eventually leading her to uncover a hidden conspiracy and secret, changing her fate completely. YouTube Video Placeholder
Talking about PE, here a sum up of the entire franchise (so far)
YouTube Video Placeholder |
|
|
By . on 2026-01-12 16:03:31 |
|
|
|
|
|
but having something like sTP instead would make this set super unbalanced vs other 4. doesn't need to be STP or a offense focused stat at all.
looking at the set something like SIRD would have made sense, maybe conserve MP, SED feels shoehorned in. |
|
 |
By Garuda. Chanti on 2026-01-12 15:26:43 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
 |
By Eiryl on 2026-01-12 14:39:23 |
|
Is Spirit Taker 1:1 damage:mp
With all the crazy *** gear won't it give more mp than myrkr (when its safe to spirit taker instead of myrkr, obviously)
|
|
|
|
I was still under the impression that only HQ2 would be able to reach Rank 30 when I posted that. That's why I asked if there was any confirmation or not. It was initially speculated this may be the case. With the knowledge that the +1 version can reach R30 then yes, I agree the set is a lot more appealing. The magnifient set looks really good imo.
It's still not even close to being as good as you wrote though. Feet being slightly better or brake even vs Malignance, Kendatsuba or AF+4, while having less meva than Malignance and Kendatsuba.
Body is good for impetus down, but it's not a massive gain over alternatives. Legs and hands aren't an upgrade at all. Head is good upgrade if you are missing Nyame. |
