With the augments surely it brings both items up to par being slightly behind 119 AG REMA. The stats are actually pretty good after fully augmented.
Its not even close.
- Liberator is good, because of huge bonus to Insurgency and AM3
- Apocalypse is good, because of utility
- Redemption is good, because of AM3 white damage offset the fact that scythe WSs without augments are only good at 2000+ TP. Also 50 STR/MND/INT adds quite a lot WS damage to all Scythe WSs.
- Anguta is good, because 500TP bonus helps a lot to get to 2000 effective TP and it makes Entropy a viable option for skillchains
Without those specific perks regular scythes are far behind
Agwu's claymore might not be that far behind for Resolution spam I guess if you can't put AM3 up on Caladbolg, but that's niche. Caladbolg with AM3 and doing Torcleavers is again far ahead.