Asura.Shermansmith said:
»"The world is the main character, the player is the story and the community is the content." kid3050 who made a youtube video recently about leaving Blizzard because of the direction of WoW and it's virtual world. I thought I'd leave the quote here. Please note, I'm not comparing wow to ffxi or vis a versa.
I watched his video and I agree. Modern developers (this is far less of an issue on FFXI but they have totally destroyed wow with care bear mentality) and players are starting to forget that it's not the content as much as the people that make these games so interesting and worth playing. The things that made the MMORPG genre so awesome was the worlds and the thing that made the worlds interesting was the people. Virtual worlds used to be so fun because you could be anything and do anything without the restraints you get irl, now people treat online like it's real life. muh harassment of my virtual character, muh offended, muh bullying, muh w/e
When you think back about on FFXI (or wow) what are the memorable moments? The people! the weirdos, the trolls, the asshats that stole your stuff, the party that camped ontop of you and made everyone mad, the freaks, the bad guys, the mpk trains, the guy that walked up and popped the nm you were about to spawn and waited for the other guy to finish on, the sloot that fooled the linkshell leader into getting more drops and then turned out to be a guy, the guy that stole your NM. You felt like you were logging into a real world because you were, the people made it a real experience. It was hilarious, and every day was unpredictable.
These virtual worlds need more freedom and less complainers, they need bad guys, they need a living breathing world where you don't know what it gonna happen today when you login. When everything is sanitized it's BORING and when it's boring you might as well just do RL crap, it's predictable. You login, do what you logged in to do and then you logout with nothing out of the ordinary happening outside of if you got the drop or not. If everyone is controlled and afraid to me mean they might as well be all NPCs in an offline game.
Modern mmos are way too sanitized cause people *** about muh toxic people. I love toxic people, they are the spice that keeps you logging in or coming back. You know how boring it is when everyone is not "toxic" and everyone is "nice" and nobody disagrees? This is why modern mmorpgs suck, because there is no "world". It's just an extension of real life now and everyone is policed and controlled.
I still remember my first collibri party on bard when another party of evil satanic devil worshipping puppy punchers camped ontop of us and ruined our xp, and everyone got real mad and went into Super Saiyan (and by super saiyan I meant we were on the bring of wiping constantly) mode and we had 5 mobs slept and the other party was doing the same, we were talking trash to each other in say, we were casting dia on mobs the other party had slept, we mocked them and sent mean tells when anyone died, our hearts were racing. Then when they left 3 hours later we all said how great it was cause we made them leave and we won! (even though it was 3 hours and they were gonna leave anyway). This would never happen in a modern mmo because they would design it in a way so there was no limited resources in the first place that would cause the drama.
This is why people loved HNM so much, it was "toxic" as all hell and that's why it was so fun.
I remember the first time playing a non FFXI mmorpg and being unable to leave the town because there was some high level tophats killing everyone on the bridge, this went on for 3-4 hours and the town had 50-100 people unable to leave. At the time I was furious because I just wanted to level but looking back on it now it was glorious, I still remember it because it was so exciting and strange. Then some high level "good guys" came and killed them and a semi war happened for 30 mins while we watched and jeered and cheered in world chat until they they got bored and left. That would never happen these days, not only would they design the game so you can't do it the GMs would ban them for harassment or something.
Honestly even now in hippy 2020 FFXI is still one of the better experiences because the GMs still put far less control over people than something like FF14. They still respect the chaos of the world.