|
What makes a {Veteran} vs {Amateur} player?
Serveur: Bismarck
Game: FFXI
Posts: 65
By Bismarck.Funstealer 2017-01-24 08:33:32
what do u call it when u used to know everything 3 years ago then came back to the game recently and know jack ***about the content now a days
[+]
Asura.Saevel
Serveur: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 9910
By Asura.Saevel 2017-01-24 08:38:54
Bismarck.Funstealer said: »what do u call it when u used to know everything 3 years ago then came back to the game recently and know jack ***about the content now a days
Do you know game mechanics? If you do then you can easily get caught up on current stuff because the foundation is already there.
Otherwise your were in the amateur category to begin with and just were lucky enough to know some veterans who did the hard part for you.
[+]
Lakshmi.Buukki
Serveur: Lakshmi
Game: FFXI
By Lakshmi.Buukki 2017-01-24 09:08:05
Meh, its even simpler than that. Just plug in your information on this Store TP Calculator and you literally have your value.
It could be off because it hasn't been updated since 2012, but it certainly gives a great ballpark which has worked for me.
No, just use the damn formula on Wiki and your calculator application on your PC. Using an outdated incorrect online calculator because your too lazy to do it yourself is the very definition of "amateur". I just outlined how easy it was to figure out, find your weapon of choice on the wiki, and it's base TP value should be listed (most are already updated). If it's not then use the formula on the wiki for the delay to find it's base value. Then just run the numbers real quick to determine your needed Store TP and go from there.
This ***is on a "I'm too lazy to mess with macros their just too complicated and I don't need them, I'm good enough as is".
So far as I can tell there has been no updated calculator since the last round of changes, which were pretty damn significant.
You're right, I shouldn't be advocating and recommended outdated information. Thanks for pointing us to the right source.
I have since downloaded FFXI Calculator Tool, as I didn't know it existed.
Lakshmi.Buukki
Serveur: Lakshmi
Game: FFXI
By Lakshmi.Buukki 2017-01-24 09:09:28
Meh, its even simpler than that. Just plug in your information on this Store TP Calculator and you literally have your value. OMG who's this Robert Heck? I love that! Are there other calculators on his site?
I always used to do the TP calculation on my own using the wiki formulas but that's so boring! I love this! :D
Don't use this one I mentioned. Its outdated and may be off a point or two. Use the method above.
Serveur: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 1326
By Asura.Azagarth 2017-01-24 09:12:47
ffxi calc is running like 24/7 on my comp lol.... I use it for a ton of stuff, its very handy and a must along with windower in my book.
[+]
Bismarck.Snprphnx
Serveur: Bismarck
Game: FFXI
Posts: 2707
By Bismarck.Snprphnx 2017-01-24 09:13:13
FFXICalc is good, and up to date, the last I saw. Has stuff for Store TP, Dual Wield, and Ranged Attacks
Bismarck.Firedemon
Serveur: Bismarck
Game: FFXI
Posts: 1325
By Bismarck.Firedemon 2017-01-24 09:32:57
Casual player = player that has been playing for a significant amount of time but for whatever reason decides to stay on the amateur side of the player equation. Tends to pull the "RL/This isn't a job" card whenever they are called out for not being able to do the bare minimum.
I disagree with this comment 100%. Over the years my playtime has dwindled down due to RL. Do I still strive for the best gear? Yes. Do I play my jobs well above a lot of people? Yes. I don't ever do the bare minimum and I'm a pretty casual player. Sure it takes me a bit longer to get gear VS the hardcores, but an amateur player is probably the last thing you could call me.
[+]
By Pantafernando 2017-01-24 09:46:57
Also, important that to notice that there is more between an "amateur" and a "veteran".
Odin.Taffy
Serveur: Odin
Game: FFXI
Posts: 79
By Odin.Taffy 2017-01-24 09:54:30
Veteran player = Fought in the Crystal war. Generally very poor. Often seen sitting in town just hoping someone invites them in their mog house and offers them some sublime sushi. Generally always willing to help the less fortunate and always the last to lot items.
Amateur player = Omg I got all my crafts maxed now I should start gearing a job.
[+]
By Afania 2017-01-24 11:19:32
I could care less if someone has a youtube channel, there are plenty of videos showing nothing but players revisiting FFXI after quitting X amount of years/months. There's only a very small handful of players creating strat videos. Same goes for forum posts, there are plenty of players with over 10k posts, does that mean they are top tier players?
Parses also mean absolutely nothing to me as there are many factors as to why X player performed better than Y or Z player assuming all had equal skill and gear.
I don't see how player reputation has anything to do with awareness/reaction speed/knowledge either
Player reputation is directly tied into how well your perform in whatever said content a player decided to participate in. WS slowly, die repeatedly as a tank, fail to keep buffs/debuffs on, all these things directly affect how others see your skill. Do any of these things poorly and you suddenly have a ***player rep. I don't remember seeing any shouts for ***players, ever.
I'm not from Ragnarok and I've never had the pleasure of playing with you, but given the comments from various other players on this forum I can easily come to the conclusion that your rep is being one of the few non-***casual/vanilla players. (I wouldn't even label you as casual.) If I was shouting for something, I'd take you over a ***gearswap ffxiah copy-pasta dps. Why? Based on player rep.
Player rep is 100% based on talk from other players, which is 100% based on player performance.
And this is exactly what I meant by player rep has nothing to do with performance or whatsoever. You have no idea how many times I die on tank, lose hate, not curing fast enough, forgot erase, na, haste, refresh in Vagary that even my friends made fun of me for "being a casual" In terms of performance I'm probably about the same as everyone else. And yet for some reason I have some kind of rep that allows me to get invite to many high end ls or groups on Ragnarok just because I post a lot.....
Valefor.Omnys
Serveur: Valefor
Game: FFXI
Posts: 1759
By Valefor.Omnys 2017-01-24 11:21:03
Amateurs giggle at their time played. Veterans avoid that button like the plague.
Serveur: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 616
By Asura.Avallon 2017-01-24 11:34:25
Veterans set their alarm clocks for 4:00AM Tiamat windows during the HNM era.
[+]
Asura.Saevel
Serveur: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 9910
By Asura.Saevel 2017-01-24 11:51:00
And I found a problem with the FFXICalc program, it assumes your WSing and TPing in the same gear and thus have the same TP return. That and I now know why people erroneously call a 5-hit a "4-hit" set.
Lakshmi.Konvict
Serveur: Lakshmi
Game: FFXI
Posts: 878
By Lakshmi.Konvict 2017-01-24 11:55:29
Veterans set their alarm clocks for 4:00AM Tiamat windows during the HNM era. Cerb too just to farm your ls leader mats. And every hour not just 4 am. T.T
By Calinar 2017-01-24 11:57:50
And I found a problem with the FFXICalc program, it assumes your WSing and TPing in the same gear and thus have the same TP return. That and I now know why people erroneously call a 5-hit a "4-hit" set.
It's not really something you "found". You set the ws box to custom TP (amount of tp from using ws).
And it's not why people use 4 hit vs 5 hit, it's a semantics argument. Does a ws count as a hit? Who's to say, we just all agree that it does, but it's not a standard, just an agreement. (resolution is obviously not a one-hit ws, so you're obviously using an 8 hit set up, right?)
"3 hits + ws tp" = 3 hit to some, 4 hit to some, not erroneous, just opinion.
[+]
Asura.Saevel
Serveur: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 9910
By Asura.Saevel 2017-01-24 12:22:58
Yes it is. The very people who started this whole x-hit concept used the WS as your first hit precisely because that WS was a one-hit and used different Store TP then the TP build. Then other people started doing it and somehow they started magically subtracting a hit and now it's confusing when doing the path cause you got idiots saying "my 3-hit lol".
You set the ws box to custom TP (amount of tp from using ws).
The person is using it because they don't know how to do their own Store TP.
Quote: Even as a player for entire NA release, I still can't tell you if 2 random weaponskills will skillchain without *** using ffxicalc.
And that tells me all I need to know.
Bismarck.Firedemon
Serveur: Bismarck
Game: FFXI
Posts: 1325
By Bismarck.Firedemon 2017-01-24 12:37:04
If you think that the difference between an amateur and a veteran player is someone who can tell you that 2 random weapon skills can skillchain together you need to get a grip on things. That doesn't mean a damn thing.
Serveur: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 549
By Asura.Ivlilla 2017-01-24 12:44:12
Caitsith.Mahayaya said: »/yell {Normal} Chpt 2 Body {Do you need it?} (5+ 119 RMEA only) 1/6
I have literally been turned down, on DNC, for Ch1-5 fights, on difficulties that I can solo, because I was not BLU. I'm just bored as hell and want to help someone get geared, but no, I'm obviously an idiot for afterglowing a Terpsichore instead of a Tizona.
For my 2 gil, a difference between being a veteran and not is knowing what a job is capable of, what jobs are capable of filling what roles, and knowing there's a time and a place where you don't have to take the "perfect" set up.
I play WHM, DNC, and COR. That's it. For a lot of stuff I do with friends/my LS, I come as WHM. Probably 75% of the time I'm WHM. 20% I'm COR. 5% of the time I'm DNC. Even if I'm a better DD than someone else, it's either preferable for me to come on WHM than have one of our DDs go WHM, or someone there insists that DNC or COR aren't capable of DDing in the given content.
I'm entirely willing to go to crap as WHM if it gets it done and works for everyone involved and is honestly the best thing I can do in that situation. I think I am the only one in either of my linkshells with a Yagrush. I could be wrong. RMEA don't mean much anymore, and Yagrush is rather common, but I also have decent sets for everything WHM, including melee. Or it was decent until this month. So it often IS best for everyone if I come WHM.
But then there are times where we're literally doing a Zi'tah NM that I can solo on DNC, or something equally silly, and my DNC or COR gets passed over, when we already have a decent WHM, because someone else has a much crappier geared BLU.
Where was I before this became a BLU rant?
Oh, right. A veteran knows what a job's capable of, and knows what roles it can fill, and in what circumstances. I was pretty shocked during a Tojil run when the LS I was with at the time didn't understand how I was doing so much healing after the WHM died; they had no idea what Trance was. I, similarly, am ignorant about a lot about a lot of jobs, because I don't play them, but I do have a good idea of what they're capable of, especially when geared properly. I'll take a RDM to nuke on a CP party, even though it's not "the right job" to take. There's a difference between not knowing all the level 50/+ names of JAs for a job I don't play, and a difference between not even knowing DNC can heal.
Raaant.
[+]
Serveur: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 549
By Asura.Ivlilla 2017-01-24 12:54:35
Oh, and mechanics. I have explained Dual Wield to so many people in the last month that I'm tempted to write up a pastebin to explain, in the simplest possible terms, why you don't need 60% Dual Wield when you have capped gear haste and Haste II on, and why you certainly don't want any Dual Wield gear on when you're at capped gear haste, magic haste, and have a DNC doing a merited Haste Samba.
It's insanely frustrating when people ask for help, particularly with mechanics, and then just don't *** listen, despite them coming to you specifically because you seem to be better at something than they are, because it doesn't line up with what they expect or want to think.
Particularly when there's resources readily available where you can go read, in depth, about a mechanic, resources they're aware of, but can't be bothered to even scan.
[+]
Bismarck.Phaded
Serveur: Bismarck
Game: FFXI
By Bismarck.Phaded 2017-01-24 13:09:51
The vast majority of players here seriously do not understand the words they use to classify themselves as a player. Just because you have limited time does not automatically put you into the casual player category.
Do you buy Nintendo products? Do you use Wii fit? Do you play party games and apps? Are your gaming interests satisfied thru games that are over in 5 min? Then yes, you are in casual player territory.
Do you have limited time to play an MMO? Sorry, but you are just a player with limited time. There's nothing casual about you, in fact, you are just the average player (everyone has RL/limited time/kids/school/wives/etc).
Serveur: Shiva
Game: FFXI
Posts: 1052
By Shiva.Arislan 2017-01-24 13:26:07
It's insanely frustrating when people ask for help, particularly with mechanics, and then just don't *** listen, despite them coming to you specifically because you seem to be better at something than they are, because it doesn't line up with what they expect or want to think.
Particularly when there's resources readily available where you can go read, in depth, about a mechanic, resources they're aware of, but can't be bothered to even scan.
Yes, my personal favorite is when people will ask you something like "So what did you think of my (job)? Anything you notice that I can improve?"
Then they'll go full defensive and fight you point-by-point on every suggestion you offer to make, no matter how sound the reasoning behind it was.
It's FFXI's version of "does this dress make me look fat?".
Serveur: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 549
By Asura.Ivlilla 2017-01-24 14:03:52
It's insanely frustrating when people ask for help, particularly with mechanics, and then just don't *** listen, despite them coming to you specifically because you seem to be better at something than they are, because it doesn't line up with what they expect or want to think.
Particularly when there's resources readily available where you can go read, in depth, about a mechanic, resources they're aware of, but can't be bothered to even scan.
Yes, my personal favorite is when people will ask you something like "So what did you think of my (job)? Anything you notice that I can improve?"
Then they'll go full defensive and fight you point-by-point on every suggestion you offer to make, no matter how sound the reasoning behind it was.
It's FFXI's version of "does this dress make me look fat?".
It's really bad when you are not only right, but you can prove you're right, and you have both the math and the in-game proof to back you up, yet you obviously must be mistaken.
It feels like the more we try to define 'veteran' the more we're just describing 'mentally and emotionally mature person who plays this game and is capable of logic and reason'.
Being able to accept you're wrong and take correction are important.
[+]
Bismarck.Phaded
Serveur: Bismarck
Game: FFXI
By Bismarck.Phaded 2017-01-24 14:15:14
The word veteran just needs to stop being used quite honestly. Only reason anyone has ever used it in a shout is just because SE decided to add it to the auto translate dictionary.
The current dedication spectrum breaks down as follows:
N00b - Novice player
Casual - plays casual games, games less frequently than other gamers. Ex: The Sims and Nintendogs
Core - Has a wide range of gaming interests and is more likely to play different types of games
Hardcore - strives for competition, complexity, and establishing gaming communities
Of those four categories the "Core" player further breaks down into two categories. Core and Mid-Core. The mid-core gamer enjoys games but may not finish every game they buy, doesn't have time for long MMO quests and is a target consumer for Sony/Microsoft.
The vast majority of you, are either Core or Mid-core, knock it off with the "I'm a casual gamer" excuse, no ones ever bought it.
Serveur: Fenrir
Game: FFXI
Posts: 9
By Fenrir.Kemigumi 2017-01-24 14:17:26
mid-core? lol ok
Bismarck.Phaded
Serveur: Bismarck
Game: FFXI
By Bismarck.Phaded 2017-01-24 14:22:37
Yes mid-core, there's also Troll Gamer, Girl Gamer, Gaymer, Retro-gamer and Pro-Gamer. I'm not arbitrarily pulling words out of my ***, and while there is no general consensus on these definitions the attempts to formalize them are still there. When introducing the Wii-U Nintendo themselves even used the word Core Gamer. All categories can be further broken down into taxonomies: Achievers, Explorers, Socializers and Killers.
The majority of you are NOT casuals, sorry. Just either lazy or full of excuses.
[+]
Serveur: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 34187
By Asura.Kingnobody 2017-01-24 14:23:24
Here's a simple solution as to what is the difference between veterans and amateurs.
I'm awesome, it's you guys who are all scrubs
Odin.Taffy
Serveur: Odin
Game: FFXI
Posts: 79
By Odin.Taffy 2017-01-24 14:26:05
It's FFXI's version of "does this dress make me look fat?".
This comment wins the internet today. I actually Lol'd in work. Co workers looking at me funny right now.
Serveur: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 616
By Asura.Avallon 2017-01-24 14:34:06
Yes mid-core, there's also Troll Gamer, Girl Gamer, Gaymer, Retro-gamer and Pro-Gamer. I'm not arbitrarily pulling words out of my ***, and while there is no general consensus on these definitions the attempts to formalize them are still there. When introducing the Wii-U Nintendo themselves even used the word Core Gamer. All categories can be further broken down into taxonomies: Achievers, Explorers, Socializers and Killers.
The majority of you are NOT casuals, sorry. Just either lazy or full of excuses.
Oh here we go. You just lured Saevel into this conversation.
[+]
Serveur: Asura
Game: FFXI
Posts: 549
By Asura.Ivlilla 2017-01-24 14:37:47
If only there were some way to tell/find out if someone is a good player that didn't involve social interaction in the form of friends or a linkshell.
[+]
Seems to me that a good number of players don't know exactly what makes a "Veteran" player. Normally in shout groups, you'll see someone asking for "SMN {Veteran} PLD {Veteran}". I happen to shout fairly regularly for various groups, and I use the term often.
However, from time to time, when I push back and ask if they are a veteran at their job, sometimes they reply "define veteran". Some people don't really know what makes a veteran player vs an average player, and was wondering what the community's general consensus and benchmark for being considered "Veteran". Because while there is clearly an acceptable standard of what is expected of a player when they join an event, there are also (at times) an unrealistic benchmark that give players a bad vibe as to what they are expected to have before joining something (Ever see a shout for something like Leviathan VD or SR asking for a REMA BLU ?)
Here's my list of what I would and would not consider criteria for being a Veteran:
A {Veteran} {Job} must:
• Have to be able to follow a strategy. This may include skillchains, magic bursts, and other things.
• Have invested a good amount of time into the job. Simply being lvl99 and geared is not enough anymore.
• Understand when to use JAs/Spells and how they affect monsters/party. You cannot be a WAR and not understand why you need to merit Savagery (Warcry). Unacceptable.
• Must possess all WS/JAs and spells that are expected at any level of play, including seemingly useless ones, unless they are extremely impractical in nearly every scenario (This may be debatable depending on what job you play. WAR probably doesn't need to unlock Stardiver, for instance); i.e. COR should have every roll, no exceptions. You do need to buy spells like Frazzle 1 and Flurry 1, even if you have the lvl2 version on your RDM main.
• All Support jobs unlocked for your main. This includes /sch for mage, /sam, /drk, /run for DD, and /blu for tanks.
• Possess a DT50% build, or very very close to it. No exceptions, mage, tank, or melee.
• [If you're a DD] Possess the requisite amount of accuracy for the content. If you're a mage, you will need magic accuracy for the content.
• [If you're a DD] Have advanced job knowledge and monster mechanics. You cannot just spam CDC all day. You'll need to visit forums and websites to learn some things. You'll also need to know what you're fighting before we fight it. Do a small bit of research.
• [If you're a DD] Have "sets" for different situations, and the appropriate gear that augment special abilities, like Diffusion and Angon. This is very important as it adds some pretty potent boons from just having it equipped on activation. (It drives me crazy when I see 3~minute diffusion MG from BLUs)
• If you're a tank, you may need an REMA, or maybe not...at the very least a combination of good play, good gear, and great sets (including enmity, damage taken, healing, and occasional DD) to be worth inviting.
• If you're a mage, must have all skill levels unlocked/maxed.
Maxed Potency which is reasonably attainable through time and gear (for instance, 900 skill GEO, High lvl Bar spell WHM or max Curna set for WHM)
• [If on job that uses MP] Possess a FC set. It's no longer acceptable to take 4 full seconds to cast stoneskin.
• You need to bring meds, regardless of your job. This includes RR, Vile+1 if needed, silent oils if needed, remedy/holy water/panacea/echo drops at the very least. This is probably debatable, but it makes the difference sometimes.
A {Veteran} {Job} does not need:
• Master JP. Master is not required, but certainly helps your argument, as it means you've spent time on your job and you're more likely to understand it.
• a REMA, though it certainly doesn't hurt and may make you more attractive in content.
• HQ abjurations or the like. You could be an above average geared player and perform well. But gear does make a ton of a difference, so it doesn't hurt to have "good gear".
• To have cleared said content previously, but it helps to have some knowledge of the NM and its tricks.
• To be the best of the best, elitist by some people's terms.
Discuss how you would define a Veteran Player. I hope this thread can actually educate some people who may have been unfamiliar with what the term specifically meant, because I have noticed it has different meanings depending on who you ask. Its good to get the answer out in the open.
|
|