Actually I also have access to the node, and I actually update it, occasionally ¯\_(ツ)_/¯.
Wasn't replying to you, nor I see how "Byrne has access" even relevant to the discussion when I was talking to the other guy. Plus I was the only person who asked for access for quite a while, henced I used past tense "when he quit", it implys right at that moment.
Anyways, this wasn't the point. I don't know why you feel like you have to comment on this when the discussion is already over 2 pages ago.
Also at attack cap, while 50K savage blade is not common,
Thanks for repeating the same thing that I just said.
it's not all that rare, either (assuming a perfect set).
This is contradicting to the last sentence, and your own video.
Someone just linked your video, if 50k isn't that rare, we would see at least 1 50k savage in a 4 min video.
Prehaps I missed a 50k savage from your video? If I did then please tell me the time stamp of the 50k in the video.
Or prehaps we have different understanding of what "is not uncommon" "not all that rare" means. If you can't get one 50k in 4 min of spamming savage on apex with cor brd geo buffs, to me it's not common at all, and extremely rare.
I know a couple of NM just seems to take extremely high ws dmg than normal, such as one of the mid boss in Omen, escha kirin. I do not know why they take so much damage, more so than what math says what savage should be doing.
But I would say that's more of a special case if anything. And certainly doesn't impact DD RDM since other jobs can also pop high ws spikes in that situation.
Here is how you could prove I'm wrong. Try bloster frailty on apex mob, buff with chaos/dia4/fury, spam savage at 1000 TP for 5 min. Post gear sets, buffs, ws avg and ws spikes in a scientific way. Let math and evidence speak themselves for the reader.
If evidence prove me wrong because there are several 50k savages happened entire time, then I'll gladly admit I'm wrong in this case. Otherwise I don't think it's not unreasonable to call people out for misword things.
Back then when people argued about polearm hierarchy in DRG bg guide, or MNK subtle blow impact on kill speed. There were endless pages of pointless arguments and posts too.
As soon as sim/spreadsheet numbers are posted and videos are made, it's settled. I'm convinced 100% with 0 doubt. I went from very skeptical about people's claim on certain side, to 100% support whoever posted the evidence.
If you want to convince me that 50k isn't rare at all, prove it. Then I promise I'll admit I'm wrong in this case. I have several post history to prove that I generally eat my words if I'm proven wrong with math or evidence, so I'm not THAT stubborn about things.
As for the comment about RDM having lower white damage, RDM has enspells.
I don't think we talk about RDM white damage here at all.
but there's no need to be so rude,
Here is the thing, seeker said this:
Afania, if I had a *** I'd ask you to get off it. Since I don't, I'll share the sentiment instead.
You, personally, you, Afania the main COR with a widely displayed dislike of anything that resembles a red mage doing anything but Haste/Flurry/debuffs or whatever else, do not belong in a serious discussion on how to improve DD sets YOU said you'd never utilize.
Tacothecat said this:
Cerberus.Tacothecat said:
»Apparently you get into these immature debates often. I have zero desire to put up with that, blocking you, have a good life.
I didn't get "rude" until they start it first.
I think you are pretty biased for saying I'm rude but completely ignored the fact that they are the one being rude first.
If you ever see my post history, I don't go out and be rude at people for fun. I usually just point out someone's info being wrong, or misleading, or have an opinion that I disagree with and that I feel their opinion is way too subjective to the point that it could hurt the community. And I rarely resort to personal attack nor making assumptions when I disagree.
Then whoever got facts point out or feel I twist their words(usually because they misword things first, or didn't make things clear for the reader), got mad and resort to personal attack, and make claims that I'm directing toward them.
But no, it's either facts, or it isn't. If what I said isn't a fact, prove it with evidence. If you feel I twist your words, just clarify it again. I am always open to evidence and strongly believe that in forum discussions it's either evidence/facts or bust.
saying that you simply haven't seen something and claiming that it is impossible is called an argument from personal incredulity. One of those logical fallacy things, if you recall.
Except I've seen it, and I said over, and over, and over again that
50k is entirely possible, I just don't think it's common.. Here is what I wrote since appearantly you didn't read it.
50k savage isn't normal number on both jobs, spreadsheet doesnt show such number and not even close, even with 55% wsd. Though in escha or on certain NM 50k spike could happen from time to time, it's certainly not a common thing with gears equip-able these days,
And pretty much all of the videos and evidences posted in this thread supported my opinion. Then Tacothecat got mad because of my statement above, which is not incorrect in any way, nor even rude.
If you want to jump into the discussion, at least read what other people wrote instead of twisting their words, or else you're just putting more fuel to the fire.
I wonder if mod can lock this thread for a bit, so peole stop jumping in and make random comment focusing at poking people and twisting people's words which are totally irrelevant and not contributing to the discussion.
This discussion should end 2 pages ago unless someone want to contribute something with spreadsheet math/videos/parses to prove something.