SE gave us stupidly awesome 119 AF1, which is extrememly out of character for them. Other than 119 AF3+2 hands, expect nothing for the next 3 years.
Relic feet +1 are pretty amazing also but I get what you mean & you are probably right. I love people ask them for THF to be a better DD and they still come out and talk about how they have plans to give THF more hate control tools.
Anyone messed around with Vajra on test server recently? 15 days till my Vajra will be finished and I'm spreadsheeting Mandalic Stab sets now. Just curious if anyone has some insights or thoughts regarding usage/sets on my troll toy.
You can kinda predict how the stats are gonna turn out by comparing the trends between 109 to 119 for other AF/relic, and then what's on the 109 body. It'll probably look close to this:
Yetshila
Critical hit rate +1% Critical hit damage +5 WAR, RDM, THF, DRK, NIN, COR, RUN
Yetshila +1
Critical hit rate +2% Critical hit damage +6 WAR, RDM, THF, DRK, NIN, COR, RUN
That ammo is definitely a worthy contender to replace the venerable raider's boomerang, especially considering how much crit rate / crit damage gear we're getting with the AF/relic upgrades. I would guess (just completely off the top of my head) that it would be far more useful in party situations, where you already have lots of magic haste and may be near a delay cap.
For solo farming though, I'm going to stick to the boomerang just so I have an easy pulling method.
Also, relevant TH notes:
SE said:
Upper limits of Treasure Hunter including the total of bonuses provided by equipment, atma, and job abilities.
Thief
Treasure Hunter +8
* The limit will be raised to +12 as normal when under the increased Treasure Hunter effects granted through thief autoattacks, Sneak Attack, Trick Attack, and the ranger ability Bounty Shot.
So that means you have TH3 (JA), +1 from raider's poulaines +2, +2 from assassin's armlets +2, +1 from thief's knife, and +1 from the new Chaac Belt to hit the cap, unless you're in Abyssea and you use the atma. That means the Knife isn't outdated just yet.
It is also nice of SE to tell us what the TH cap from proc'ing is.
I haven't touched the Raider's Boomerang in months. It's been all Honed Tathlum + Qirmiz Tathlum. Starting to consider getting rid of my normal TP set. These days, it's either full acc or pdt/mdt gear.
The bad part is that on content where you really need heavy acc, you probably don't want that Enmity+7 on while you TP unless you feel like THF tanking (I'm guessing you don't!) AF119 or Kaabnax seem like they might be a better choice when you want Acc given the circumstances.
AGI (slightly less than Nahtirah) and STR (slightly more than Nahritah) and Accuracy: Exenterator or Mercy Stroke piece? Especially TA+WS for the Enmity transfer.
It seems like a pretty niche piece though. Prob gonna leave mine at 109 for a while (gogo Feint augment).
Enmity doesn't matter since you should be hitting hate cap very fast regardless. If you're concerned about hitting hate cap, you might as well wear weaker gear or not WS all together. No one ever advocated using Novia Earring for their WS set.
And Pillager legs+1 for anything Mercy Stroke, and that won't change for a long, long time.
So that means with equipment and JAs, you start with TH8. You do a hate action on the monster, TH8 is on. The first proc message you see will say "TH9", because TH8 is applied on the first hate action without a visible proc, and the proc adds one to that.
We can toss the knife when we get one more TH bonus from a non-dagger source, beyond the belt that we just got. When that is the case, you can use entirely non-dagger equipment to start at the equipment/JA cap of TH8, and you can choose your dagger selection in order to maximize TH proc chances or damage at your leisure.
Enmity doesn't matter since you should be hitting hate cap very fast regardless. If you're concerned about hitting hate cap, you might as well wear weaker gear or not WS all together. No one ever advocated using Novia Earring for their WS set.
Eh, guess you're right. Even so, if given a choice between (1) hitting hate cap very fast versus (2) hitting hate cape +7 enmity faster, I'll go with the first one. Wish they'd just give up with the enmity+ gear already, the legs would be nicer as just a heavy acc piece without that extra stat.
There's nothing special about the spot in the middle that you insist on taking because you can continue to slide to the right. If you're really concerned about enmity, WS in -enmity gear and do lousy damage.
I'm really not that concerned with enmity+. I'd just rather not have it on the piece instead of S-E clinging to the useless "THF has enmity tools" line. Really not that big of a deal though, it's not why I or anyone else is making the THF DD gear selections they do.
But are you saying Plunderer+1 are BETTER than Pillager+1? Really, for what? And if that's not what you're saying... who cares about this sliding scale. Just don't use Plunderer, except for maybe the very rare situations where you really need a max acc build on THF.
Pretty sure I said the complete opposite a few posts back.
The sliding scale was a hypothetical that was following your nonsense logic when you said this
Quote:
Even so, if given a choice between (1) hitting hate cap very fast versus (2) hitting hate cape +7 enmity faster, I'll go with the first one.
In fact, you were the one who suggested that Plunderer might be better.
Quote:
AGI (slightly less than Nahtirah) and STR (slightly more than Nahritah) and Accuracy: Exenterator or Mercy Stroke piece? Especially TA+WS for the Enmity transfer.
You are literally trying to call me out for a statement that you and only you made, and that I specifically rebutted against.
Looked around at the pages you quoted and it showed one confirmed path for Tinhaspa of:
Accuracy+15, DEX+12, DMG+5
This likely means the STR Path is similar so Im guessing
Attack+15, STR+12, DMG+5
This officially marks the death of Oatixur having a higher Damage than Oatixur and better stats on either path. Fair well my friend, you have indeed served me well T.T
As for which path to chose, I did not see what the 3rd path is on that post Alistrianna provided but for now, I would recommend having both lol <.<;
Use DEX/Acc Path for anything that has HELP I AM TRAPPED IN 2006 PLEASE SEND A TIME MACHINE Amounts of Evasion, such as AAs or the Yorcia Tier IV NM or the Tier V Khamir Drifts NM after It has leveled up 2 or 3 times O.o;
Use STR/Attack Path for anything that doesn't dodge the IRS to completely destroy it.
Both of these have more Accuracy than Oatixur so you cant really go wrong on either end but even the guys that own Spharai will want to take note that the DEX path has a total of +29 Accuracy So any serious MNKs will probably need these.
Quoted from MNK forum, assuming same augment paths for dagger as well.
You are literally trying to call me out for a statement that you and only you made, and that I specifically rebutted against.
You're trying to build nothing into a fight. I'm not disagreeing with you.
I don't think you understood what I was trying to say about enmity, but maybe it's my fault for not being clear enough. You said THF will cap enmity fast through TP no matter what. I agree! I just added that since you're already capping enmity quickly, you'll get to that point even faster if your gear has enmity+ (all other stats being equal). That's all.
I was just tossing out some questions/possibilities of situations off the top of my head where Plunderer +1 legs might be worth considering, for conversation. You shot down Mercy Stroke pretty quickly, and you're probably right! Maaaaybe it's still a best option for Exenterator (no crit, multi-hit) when you need acc thanks to the combination of AGI/STR/Acc. That's pretty niche though, and I'm definitely grasping at straws to find a place for Plunderer's legs to fit. More realistically is that it's just not that important to upgrade since the times you'll really need that max acc piece are quite rare.
Because you're giving BS 'advise' to an already shrinking talent pool.
And no, you're not just saying it. You're advising it. Going back to this post again.
Quote:
Even so, if given a choice between (1) hitting hate cap very fast versus (2) hitting hate cape +7 enmity faster, I'll go with the first one.
Novice players could easily look at that, think it's a good idea and factor enmity into their sets.
Stop with the petty excuses already. You go from throwing out moronic suggestions to accusing me of saying something you said, and now you're trying to play the innocent victim.
You're such a pleasant person, that's why I come back.
Just so I don't confuse any novice players, don't factor enmity into your gear choices. All I meant by:
Quote:
Even so, if given a choice between (1) hitting hate cap very fast versus (2) hitting hate cape +7 enmity faster, I'll go with the first one.
is that I wish S-E would stop putting enmity on THF DD gear out of some misguided belief that we care about using THF to manage enmity with TA like people might have in a 2004 era exp party. We swing a dagger really fast. We cap enmity fast already. It would be nice if it took a little longer to do so by not having enmity+ stats on our JSE gear. Oh well, we can deal.
And Plunderer+1 legs still aren't that good, unless you're in some situation where you need mega-acc at the cost of the better stats on other pieces (Pillager+1, Quiahuiz, etc.)
I like it, personally. I'd up my enmity+ merits from 5 to 10 or higher if I could, and I don't know a single serious melee players who aren't 5/5 enmity. There are only a few select situations where having hate is not a good idea and those are far and few between to mold your character around.
And Plunderer+1 legs are still good since it has the highest acc for the slot, unless you can get higher with the new delve leg augments. There are plenty of things where you won't cap hit rate unless you're super buffed, and you're not always super buffed.
Btw, in case you haven't noticed, SE didn't 'put' enmity+ on them. 119 AF2 is based off of AF2, and AF2 legs already had a high amount of enmity on them already.
Neat. So 21STR feet if I'm reading this right, that's probably new best Mercy Stroke feet. New highest acc for hands/feet without needing to trade off pdt. So it's not all useless. Makes me feel like I've wasted a lot of time doing skirmish3.