Bismarck.Helel said:
Why do you want a mnk anyway? With three players, the thf + dd will get weapons so it doesn't really matter what job you choose. Also a RDM can heal just as well as a WHM in salvage, if not better (especially on the early floors). I've done blu thf rdm, sam thf rdm, nin thf rdm, and been able to clear all possible NMs + chariot. You may in fact want a NIN if you plan on doing discoid chariot, though it's not necessary.
Really haven't done any salvage since level cap increase/entry requirement decrease, so I was just going based off what I knew was good "back in the day". I'd certainly be up for whatever setup works best. I'd also assume that with people focusing so much on the "proc jobs", people would have multiple jobs to offer. I myself have played monk for years, was just never my main so I was never high priority on lotting bb items, also have ninja leveled and pretty well geared, so I wouldn't expect to only go on my thief if someone wanted to go on a different job based on the zone/boss we were after on a given night. Same goes for any healer that wants to go...I assume that if someone enjoys healing well enough to actually be good at it, more than likely they have more than one to offer, i.e. WHM OR RDM, etc.